Mario`s Italian Kitchen Incorporated in East Setauket

The food was fantastic and so is this service!

Reasonably priced and very good quality. Great service from the front to the waitstaff. Definitely going back.

Would absolutely recommend visiting this place. Excellent vibes, delightful dishes, fantastic customer service. They never disappoint.

Have been going here for YEARS, food is still Great

Excelent food and service, very reasonable in price as well

Best Italian food in Suffolk. I recommend the eggplant rolatini.Parking is very good and the people are even better! Enjoy your time here with the different rooms and atmospheres. Very neat setup that they did. My favorite part is the bar with the raised seating. Very cool to be there.

An old school place dimly lit and good food. Great family restaurant

Great place to meet friends food is good I miss pizza... Could have been a five star rating if you still served pizza!

Loved every minute of it! We went on a Friday night. Live band. And our waitress. Candice is amazing! Will definitely go back!

This spot is my preferred one. I go to a lot of restaurants but to this one I constantly return again and again. The stuff is very friendly and the food they place on your table is so tasty. I never decline to have a nice meal in this restaurant. I highly recommend this place.

Went to Mario‘s for a networking luncheon today, and I have to say, both the food and the service were outstanding. Our server, I believe his name is CJ, outstanding customer service, I cannot say enough about him and how he handled the whole group. And the food was outstanding as usual. This is a definite must on your list of places to go!

Very nice employees and atmosphere. Food is excellent.

I really want to give this restaurant three stars - The food was awesome, but I agree with some of the other reviews that talk about the lackluster service. The first thing I was trained to do when I was a waiter back in college was welcome people to the restaurant, introduce myself and ask if they've been there before... no my waitress asked me what I wanted to drink, tried so hard to not make eye contact it made me wonder if I had food in my teeth. She was informative when I asked her a question about the menu, but it always disappoints me when a waitress/waiter doesn't come back to check on me. I ordered side house salad that was delicious, and the presentation was really nice. I had the penne alla vodka and added grilled chicken and it was so good I wanted to lick my plate. My Takeaway very good food, nice wine selection, fair prices but next time I think I'll sit at the bar.

Great restaurant. We had a back, private table and had a good time with friends. The service was excellent. The food is always terrific. The only problem is the appetizers are so good, that we can never finish our food. One of the things I like most about Mario’s is how fresh the ingredients are. You can definitely tell how high quality the food is.

This place is my number one place. Of all restaurants I know I like it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to visit this place. Whenever I I need a good lunch, this place comes first to my head. Great and all sorts of food and a rich cuisine.courteous crew, and agreeable atmosphere. And very important, the bill is honest. I suggest this restaurant with no hesitation.

Nick the waiter was great. Food fresh.

Great atmosphere. Entertainment was phenomenal on Friday night

I'm torn between giving this 4 and 5 stars. I think this restaurant does it's job very well. It is open late. They treated us with decent service, and had decent food with good portion sizes. My only criticism is that the food is all a little bit too "standard" for my tastes. (Most of the things on the menu are pasta/chicken + red sauce and cheese).

I had my bridal shower here in February of 2019. So happy my sister picked Mario’s. She said the staff was amazing to deal with from the moment she reached out. She went in and met with one of the managers and he took time to show her the place, explain the menu, and other options for the party. On the day of, the staff was very helpful with getting everything ready. They were also very friendly and attentive. Most importantly the food was delicious! I highly recommend Mario’s and look forward to returning.

This is a very nice place. Went here for mothers day, and had been in the restaurant in the past, but the food and wait service was exceptionally good. The only reason why I did not do 5 stars is because the lady at the reception desk said someone will be with you shortly, did not ask if we had a reservation? then she proceeded to help some lady with a take out order who came after us. A waitress came over and said do you have a reservation, and we gave our name and she seated us, and it was all uphill from there.

My first time there, and the meal was delicious. The eggplant lasagna was tender, tasty, just perfect. I was there for a birthday party, we had our own room. The room was attractive and comfortable. I will be returning.

We loved having a large private room, including private bathrooms, for our event. Although service was slow it gave us time to give speeches and gifts to our honored guest. Everyone enjoyed the food. The location is easy to find. We would choose to have other events here.

Delicious food.... beautifully decorated...Joey,our waiter was professional and friendly!.. great service!

Love it here! Helpful staff, great food

Like a table in the bar vicinity...not too loud even with music...service, good really good..recommend seafood and pasta dishes...

This place obviously knows how to satisfy their clients. Regularly with a super friendly mindset. The food is conveniently priced, constantly delicious and clean.

Great Food and wonderful service. The staff is amazing.

I really kinda hate to tell everyone just how good Mario's is .. if the secret gets out, it may become too busy for me to get into .. lolThey gave an excellent bar and staff.The food is exactly what they say it is .. no glamorizing details needed when good is good.Not over priced .. definitely getting your money's worth.If you're there for lunch, take advantage of the specials and your pretty much guaranteed to be going home with half your meal.They have a good wine selection .. multiple bar options .. and enough non-alcoholic choices for those who choose not to imbibe that day.Generally there are about six dessert options .. three to four of which are made there or homemade .. all of which are fresh and tasty.I'm sure they've had an off day or experience for someone (as all businesses do) but I've never experienced one.I really hate to let the secret out, but Mario's is truly a go-to option when you just don't want to worry about anything.

Great place, beautiful decor. Delicious food and excellent service, its just perfect if you wanna go on a date or to have some good times at the bar.

Mario's is the best. I've gotten take out the past few times but inside is so nice if you're trying to go on a very fancy dinner. prices aren't even super expensive, and yet their food is great! my girlfriend loves theirs tortellini Alfredo, and I've loved their meatball hero as well as their spaghetti!

It is always a pleasure to eat at Mario my favorite dish is continuously the salmon oreganato I really enjoy when Nick serves he is a great server

Very pleasant atmosphere. The food is consistently good !

One of the best Italian restaurants around. Can’t wait till they reopen.

Food was great and reasonably priced. They are also very friendly to everyone!

Went to a bridal shower here, the food was awesome and loved the friendly staff!

The food is absolutely delicious.

Food was pretty good. Good service

Expensive but well worth it. Terrific pasta dishes and great veal, so tender. Staff is awesome too. Will be back.

Food was absolutely delicious. Nicely decorated and impeccable service.

Great Italian restaurant. Food is Delicious. Great staff. I recommend this place.

Really good Italian food and service. The server Casey was awesome. Definitely coming back.

Great Italian food, read-only priced drinks, and entertainment! Add a capable and helpful staff, and this is a great local Resteraunt!

Whether your dining out with your other half, kicking it with the ladies or having a party--Marios has a place for you!!! The food and cocktails always meet expectations and every dish on the menu is phenomenal!! The staff is knowledgeable and the waiters and waitresses know how to approach you while dining. Unlike those other places that ask how is everything for the 5th time when you haven't even took a bite yet. Enjoy your visit!!!

We were in a Beautiful room for a special occasion. Service and food were fantastic and the wine was flowing. Very nice evening.

What can I say but that they ALWAYS provide great food and great service in a very comforting and homey yet stylish setting where the locals gather to unwind with friends.

Food is just ok, atmosphere and accommodation wonderful.

The food is bad. This is Italian food on Long Island? No way! Watery microwaved marinara sauce, terrible presentation as well. The atmosphere is very strange all different rooms with mish mosh decor. On top of it all, there were many flies around the restaurant. Places like this remind me of kitchen nightmares. A few positives which brought my star rating from 1 to 2. Very clean bathroom and friendly staff, but still not enough of a reason to dine here.

Very high end for me, not cheap and the portions seem small. But dinner was beyond delicious and the service was good. I definitely recommend getting one of the import beers on tap, they are a lovely treat.

My wife and I enjoyed our Saturday evening meal tonight. It was a bit loud at first but became quieter as the crowd thinned. Our Eggplant Rolattini appetizer was mild and tasty and the third serving was our first entry into our take-home bag.My wife had the Meatball with Linguine meal and I had the Chicken Francesa with Salad meal. We enjoyed a deep red wine: Ruvei Barbera d'Alba 2015 Marchesi di Barolo. For dessert we shared their Chocolate Molten Lava Cake served with whip cream and vanilla ice cream. It was a perfect ending to an excellent dinner.Edit: upon review of our itemized receipt, I see they charged us for a Shrimp entree which we did not order or get served. I called back and they credited us with a $30 gift card. Fair enough.

One of my preferred places to grab some food. very good location, always clean, and good customer service. Very good job!